Kyle. Where did you see about AA luggage tags online?
IHG group (interncontinental, etc.) made some really nice ones a few years back which had a metal frame. They sent me 2 of them when I made "Ambassador" level with them, which since I have been Marriott loyal, I am not sure if that level still exists. It was one level above platinum (for Holiday Inn, Intercontinental, Crowne Plaza, etc.).
Do you have Holiday Inn or Intercontinental hotels in Hawaii?
How was your weekend?